Shower Curtain vs Door Showdown: A Complete Guide

Are you renovating your bathroom and wondering whether to install a shower curtain or a shower door? Are you tired of constantly replacing your old shower curtain or cleaning your shower door? 

While curtains and doors have advantages and disadvantages, each option may be better suited for different bathroom types and lifestyles. By understanding the differences and factors to consider, you can make an informed decision and create your ideal shower experience.

In this article, you will learn the pros and cons of each option, and find out which one is best for your bathroom and personal preferences.

Shower Doors vs Shower Curtains: What is Better?

Curtains and doors are two common options for enclosing a shower space in a bathroom. While both serve the same purpose of keeping water contained, they differ in various ways. To choose the right one for your bathroom, it’s important to understand the differences and factors to consider.

They each have their pros and cons so let’s first take a look at those and then dive in deeper with comparisons based on your bathroom size and type of shower system.

Glass Shower Doors: Pros and Cons

When deciding between glass shower enclosures and curtains, weighing the pros and cons of each option and considering your personal preferences, budget, and bathroom layout is important. While frameless shower doors can offer a more elegant and hygienic solution, they may not be the best choice for every bathroom.

Pros

Aesthetic Appeal: Glass shower enclosures can add a sleek and modern look to your bathroom. They can also make your bathroom feel larger and brighter.

Durability: Glass shower enclosures are more durable than shower curtains and can last for many years with proper care.

Easy to Clean: A glass shower enclosure is easy to clean and maintain. They don’t require frequent washing or replacement, which makes them a convenient choice. One caveat is that it highly depends on whether it is a frameless shower door or framed and what the design is as some shower doors can be fussy to clean. 

Better Hygiene: Glass shower enclosures are more hygienic than shower curtains as they do not absorb water or promote mildew or mold growth.

More Water Protection: Glass enclosures provide better water protection than curtains, which can reduce the risk of water damage and mold growth.

Cons

Cost: Glass doors can be more expensive than curtains, especially if you choose high-end materials and designs.

Installation: Glass enclosures require professional installation, which can add to the overall cost.

Limited Design Options: Glass doors offer limited design options compared to shower curtains, which can be found in a wide range of colors and patterns.

Maintenance: Glass enclosures can be prone to hard water spots and mineral buildup, requiring regular cleaning with specialized products.

Safety Concerns: Glass doors can pose a safety risk if they are not properly installed or tempered. There is also a risk of shattering, which can be dangerous if the glass is not safety tempered.

Shower curtains pros and cons

A shower curtain requires a bit of thought when it comes to walk-in showers. It’s important to consider the pros and cons of each option and weigh them against your personal preferences, budget, and bathroom layout. While curtains can be a cost-effective and versatile solution, they may not be the best choice for every bathroom.

Pros

Cost-Effective: Shower curtains are generally more affordable than shower doors, making them a popular choice for those on a budget.

Easy to Install: Curtains are relatively easy to install, requiring only a curtain rod and some hooks. This makes them a popular choice for renters or anyone wanting a quick, simple solution.

Variety of Designs and Materials: Shower curtains come in a wide variety of colors, patterns, and materials, making it easy to find one that matches your bathroom decor.

Easy to Clean: Shower curtains can be removed and washed, which makes them easy to clean and maintain. They can also be replaced easily if they become stained or worn.

Versatile: Shower curtains can be used in a wide range of shower configurations and can be cut to fit any size or shape.

Good for small children: Bathtime with children can be a challenge and when you have a sliding doors in the way, it makes it even more difficult. A shower curtain can be moved out of the way so giving your child a bath is much easier and safer when you have a curtain. 

Cons

Susceptible to Mold and Mildew: Shower curtains can be susceptible to mold and mildew if not properly cared for. They must be regularly washed and cleaned to prevent bacteria buildup.

Not as Durable: Curtains are generally less durable than shower doors and may need replacing more frequently. They can also tear or rip easily if caught on a sharp object.

Limited Water Protection: Curtains may not provide as much water protection as shower doors, which can lead to water leaks and damage.

May Require a Liner: Shower curtains may require a liner to provide better water protection and prevent mold and mildew.

Limited Aesthetics: While curtains offer a wide range of designs and materials, they may not offer the same level of aesthetic appeal as shower doors, which can add to the overall style of a bathroom. 

No Light: A shower curtain blocks the light from the bathroom making it rather dark and gloomy. Unless you have a light in the shower then you may find it too dark whereas a glass shower door or frame will allow the light to pass through. 

Are Shower Curtains Outdated?

Shower doors are certainly more trendy than shower curtains. Many people doing bathroom remodels these days prefer a glass door for the reasons outlined above. However, there are definitely good reasons for having a shower curtain, in which case, the trend doesn’t matter. 

The truth is that shower curtains are not necessarily outdated, and they still offer many benefits that make them a popular choice for many bathrooms. They are a versatile and cost-effective solution that can be used in a wide range of shower configurations, from standard tubs to walk-in showers. They also come in a wide range of designs and materials, which makes it easy to find one that matches your bathroom decor.

However, it’s also true that curtains may not be the best choice for every bathroom. Some people prefer the sleek and modern look of glass shower doors, which can add value to a bathroom and offer better water protection. Glass shower doors are also easier to clean and may provide a more hygienic solution than shower curtains, which can promote the growth of mold and mildew.

Ultimately, choosing between shower doors vs curtains depends on your preferences, budget, and bathroom layout. While some people may prefer the more modern look of glass shower doors, others may prefer the versatility and affordability of shower curtains. It’s also worth noting that curtains have been around for many years and are still a popular choice in many bathrooms, which suggests that they are not outdated.

Can You Use a Shower Curtain with a Walk-In Shower?

The short answer is yes. In fact, we have a walk-in glass shower enclosure with a curtain. The longer answer is that you need to plan out your shower curtain for a walk-in shower. Below is some information you need to understand to get the right shower curtain if that is your plan.

Walk-in Showers: Curtain vs Door?

Walk-in showers are a popular choice for many homeowners, offering a modern and stylish look that can add value to a bathroom. When it comes to walk-in showers, the question of whether to use a shower curtain or a shower door is a common one. 

Here are the pros and cons of each option:

Shower curtain in walk-in shower pros

Versatile: Curtains can be used in a wide range of shower configurations, including walk-in showers, and can be cut to fit any size or shape which is especially helpful in small bathrooms.

Affordable: Shower curtains are generally more affordable than shower doors, making them popular for those on a budget.

Easy to Clean: Shower curtains can be removed and washed, which makes them easy to clean and maintain. 

Variety of Designs and Materials: Shower curtains come in a wide variety of colors, patterns, and materials, making it easy to find one that matches your bathroom decor.

Shower curtain in walk-in shower cons

Water Protection: Shower curtains may not provide as much water protection as shower doors, which can lead to water leaks and damage.

Susceptible to Mold and Mildew: Shower curtains can be susceptible to mold and mildew if not properly cared for.

Limited Aesthetics: While shower curtains offer a wide range of designs and materials, they may not offer the same level of aesthetic appeal as shower doors.

Walk-in shower door pros

Better Water Protection: Shower doors are better at keeping water inside than shower curtains, which can reduce the risk of water damage and mold growth.

Aesthetically Pleasing: Frameless shower doors can add a sleek and modern look to your bathroom and can make your bathroom feel larger and brighter.

Durability: Glass shower doors made with tempered glass are more durable than shower curtains and can last for many years with proper care.

Lots of Light: You don’t need a light in your walk-in shower when you have a glass door. 

Walk-in shower door cons

Cost: Glass shower doors can be more expensive than shower curtains, especially if you choose high-end materials and designs.

Installation: Glass shower doors require professional installation, which can add to the overall cost.

Limited Design Options: Glass shower doors offer limited design options compared to shower curtains.

Less Versatility: When you have a walk-in shower in a small bathroom or one that has weird angles then you may need to make a custom door. This limits your choice in terms of style, and type. 

Choosing the right type of walk-in shower curtain

Choosing the right type of shower curtain is important, especially for walk-in showers where standard sizes may not fit properly. Here are two types of shower curtains that are particularly well-suited for walk-in showers:

Extra Long Shower Curtains:

Extra long shower curtains are a great option for walk-in showers because they provide better coverage than standard shower curtains. They can be 72 x 84 inches or longer, providing enough coverage for a walk-in shower. This helps to prevent water from escaping onto the bathroom floor, which can reduce the risk of slips and falls. 

Weighted Shower Curtains:

Weighted shower curtains are another great option for walk-in showers, as they help to prevent water from escaping outside the shower area. Weighted shower curtains have small weights at the bottom of the curtain, which help to keep the curtain in place and prevent it from billowing or moving in the shower. This can help to reduce the risk of slips and falls, as well as prevent water damage to the bathroom floor. Weighted shower curtains come in a variety of designs and materials, making it easy to find one that matches your bathroom decor.

Choosing a shower door for a walk-in shower

When it comes to choosing the right type of shower door for a walk-in shower, there are several options to consider. Here are two types of shower doors that are particularly well-suited for walk-in showers:

Glass Shower Doors:

Glass shower doors are a popular choice for walk-in showers, as they offer a sleek and modern look that can add value to a bathroom. They also provide better water protection than shower curtains, which can reduce the risk of water damage and mold growth. Glass shower doors come in a variety of designs and materials, including clear, frosted, and textured glass. Some glass shower doors even have a self-cleaning coating that makes them easy to maintain and keep looking like new.

Water Stoppers for Walk-in Showers:

Water stoppers are another option for doorless showers, as they help to prevent water splash that gets onto your bathroom floor. Water stoppers are typically made of a flexible material, like silicone or rubber, and can be installed at the bottom of the shower door to create a barrier that prevents water from escaping. Water stoppers come in a variety of sizes and designs, making it easy to find one that fits your specific shower configuration.

Bottom Line

The choice between a shower curtain and a shower door for a walk-in shower depends on a number of factors, including personal preferences, budget, and bathroom layout. The right choice for your walk-in shower will depend on your individual needs and the specific features of your bathroom.

Regardless of whether you choose a shower curtain or a shower door, it’s important to take steps to prevent water from escaping outside the shower area. This can be done with the help of extra-long shower curtains, weighted shower curtains, glass shower doors, or water stoppers. By choosing the right type of shower curtain or shower door for your walk-in shower, you can create a functional and stylish bathroom that meets your needs and preferences.

Bathroomaholic.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Check out our Privacy Policy for more info.